diff --git a/arm9/source/game/bdri.c b/arm9/source/game/bdri.c
index f945704..760b368 100644
--- a/arm9/source/game/bdri.c
+++ b/arm9/source/game/bdri.c
@@ -2,6 +2,7 @@
 #include "vff.h"
 
 #define FAT_ENTRY_SIZE 2 * sizeof(u32)
+#define REPLACE_SIZE_MISMATCH 2
 
 #define getfatflag(uv) (((uv) & 0x80000000UL) != 0)
 #define getfatindex(uv) ((uv) & 0x7FFFFFFFUL)
@@ -369,7 +370,8 @@ static u32 AddBDRIEntry(const BDRIFsHeader* fs_header, const u32 fs_header_offse
 
         // If an entry for the tid already existed that is already the specified size and replace was specified, just replace the existing entry
         if (memcmp(title_id_be, file_entry.title_id, 8) == 0) {
-            if (!replace || (file_entry.size != size)) return 1;
+            if (!replace) return 1;
+            else if (file_entry.size != size) return REPLACE_SIZE_MISMATCH;
             else {
                 do_replace = true;
                 break;
@@ -864,10 +866,15 @@ u32 AddTicketToDB(const char* path, const u8* title_id, const Ticket* ticket, bo
 
     bdrifp = &file;
 
+    u32 add_bdri_res = 0;
+
     if ((BDRIRead(0, sizeof(TickDBPreHeader), &pre_header) != FR_OK) ||
         !CheckDBMagic((u8*) &pre_header, true) ||
-        (AddBDRIEntry(&(pre_header.fs_header), sizeof(TickDBPreHeader) - sizeof(BDRIFsHeader), title_id,
-            (const u8*) te, entry_size, replace) != 0)) {
+        ((add_bdri_res = AddBDRIEntry(&(pre_header.fs_header), sizeof(TickDBPreHeader) - sizeof(BDRIFsHeader), title_id,
+            (const u8*) te, entry_size, replace)) == 1) ||
+        (add_bdri_res == REPLACE_SIZE_MISMATCH && ((RemoveBDRIEntry(&(pre_header.fs_header), sizeof(TickDBPreHeader) - sizeof(BDRIFsHeader), title_id) != 0) ||
+            (AddBDRIEntry(&(pre_header.fs_header), sizeof(TickDBPreHeader) - sizeof(BDRIFsHeader), title_id,
+            (const u8*) te, entry_size, replace) != 0)))) {
         free(te);
         fvx_close(bdrifp);
         bdrifp = NULL;